Best Public EV Charging Strategy: A Viewpoint

electric car charging

Guy Turner
Guy Turner

Guest Contributor: A member of the e-zoomed EV Community


Guy Turner has spent 30 years in the energy and environmental sector, working in senior roles in consulting, commercial research and infrastructure project development, most recently as Strategy and Analysis Manager at EDF Renewables. He has an academic background in engineering, economics and corporate finance and has owned a Renault Zoe for 9 months.


Charging Infrastructure – Fewer Big Charging Stations Or More Smaller Units?


The government’s strategy to support the expansion of the EV market rightly highlights the important role of public charge points. Without ready access to charging points, drivers will fear they won’t be able to charge when they need it during a long journey (although this fear may be overplayed – see my previous blog on the subject of range anxiety).

In 2018, the UK Climate Change Committee recommended that the number of rapid chargers located near the major roads network needed to expand from 460 in 2016 to 1,170 by 2030, while the number of public chargers needed for ‘top-up charging’ needs to rise from 2,700 in 2016 to a staggering 27,000 by 2030.

Whilst all expansion of electric car charging systems is good for the growth of EVs, it is questionable whether this huge increase in top-up public chargers will be the most effective way of providing the necessary charging infrastructure. One of the most important considerations for a battery-electric vehicle (BEV) driver when looking for a charging point is certainty of availability. 

Tesla Charging Station
Tesla EV Charging Points

From an EV driver’s perspective, the option of using dedicated rapid charging stations seems more appealing, even if they are fewer and farther between. Crucially they can provide higher certainty of availability due to the number of charging points and short residence times. With the fastest ultra-rapid 350kW chargers, a green car can fill up with 100 miles in around 7 minutes (if capable of taking this rate of charge). If the driver is in a hurry and this top-up is enough to get to the destination they will soon be on their way, freeing up the charging post for the next user. Even with the more common 120kW to 150kW chargers a Tesla would receive an 80% charge in 30 minutes. With a bank of say 15 chargers (typical of Tesla super charging stations), they could process a minimum of 30 electric vehicles an hour.  More likely though drivers would use these stations as rapid top-ups to grab enough charge to get them to their destination where they can charge more completely. If each vehicle stayed 15 minutes, a 15 bank charging station would be able to process 60 electric vehicles an hour. 

electric car charging
Electric Vehicle Charging

Bulk, rapid charging stations probably also make better sense economically than single point on street chargers. The cost of installing a 150kW ultra-rapid chargers is in the region of £100,000, including grid costs, or around £0.6 per Watt of charging capacity.  A much slower on-street charger of 11 to 22kW is likely to cost around £6,000 to install, or £0.3 to 0.5 per Watt.  

on street electric car charging
Street EV Charging Points (London)

Even though the on-street chargers appear slightly cheaper to build per unit of capacity, the economics may work out better for the ultra-rapid chargers. This is for two reasons.  Firstly, if drivers use on-street chargers as long-term parking bays for their shopping or other errands, they could well stay beyond the useful charging period, taking up valuable charging time that could be used by other vehicles. Charging companies try to manage overstaying by increasing the tariff after a set time, but in practice this is still likely to happen. Because on-street charging stations are slow, it means drivers will have to spend several hours to gain sufficient charge to make a difference to their journey. The intention of drivers in these situations is not to charge the vehicle, and then think of something to do: it is the other way round. Their first intention is to spend time at their destination – shopping, work, leisure etc – and if they can find a charging point, so much the better. If what they are doing runs over the allocated charging time, they are unlikely to return to their vehicle to move parking bays. Overall, the incentive is probably to overstay. 

electric car charging
Electric Car Charging

In comparison, dedicated ultra-rapid charging stations are only used for the purpose of charging the vehicle. Drivers may well make use of the 15 to 30 minutes they have at the station, to grab a coffee, visit the toilet or do some essential shopping, as you would at a conventional service station. But once the driver has achieved the required charge, they are on their way and the unit is free to be used by the next customer.  

The second reason is that we humans value speed and convenience. The use of ultra-rapid chargers is priced at a hefty premium to standard electricity tariffs, 30-40p/kWh compared to an average home electricity of around 15p/kWh.  This is what we are probably willing to pay for filling up quickly with inconvenience to our journey. Incidentally, at around 40p/kWh is equivalent to filling a combustion engine car with petrol as current day petrol prices, so probably places a ceiling on what can be charged.

In summary, it looks like the combination of more intensive use and higher tariffs will make the ultra-rapid chargers the consumers choice.  Relatively slow on-street chargers will have their role too, but I suspect investment swing significantly towards ultra-rapid chargers in the near future. 


We at e-zoomed are more than happy to assist you with all your EV needs to include:

And more!  Do sign up to our e-newsletter to learn more about electric cars. Also follow us on Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter. 



Author

Ashvin Suri

Ashvin has been involved with the renewables, energy efficiency and infrastructure sectors since 2006. He is passionate about the transition to a low-carbon economy and electric transportation. Ashvin commenced his career in 1994, working with US investment banks in New York. Post his MBA from the London Business School (1996-1998), he continued to work in investment banking at Flemings (London) and JPMorgan (London). His roles included corporate finance advisory, M&A and capital raising. He has been involved across diverse industry sectors, to include engineering, aerospace, oil & gas, airports and automotive across Asia and Europe. In 2010, he co-founded a solar development platform, for large scale ground and roof solar projects to include the UK, Italy, Germany and France. He has also advised on various renewable energy (wind and solar) utility scale projects working with global institutional investors and independent power producers (IPP’s) in the renewable energy sector. He has also advised in key international markets like India, to include advising the TVS Group, a multi-billion dollar industrial and automotive group in India. Ashvin has also advised Indian Energy, an IPP backed by Guggenheim (a US$ 165 billion fund). He has also advised AMIH, a US$ 2 billion, Singapore based group. Ashvin has also worked in the real estate and infrastructure sector, to including working with the Matrix Group (a US$ 4 billion property group in the UK) to launch one of the first few institutional real estate funds for the Indian real estate market. The fund was successfully launched with significant institutional support from the UK/ European markets. He has also advised on water infrastructure, to include advising a Swedish clean technology company in the water sector. He is also a member of the Forbury Investment Network advisory committee. He has also been involved with a number of early stage ventures.

Sign up for e-zoomed news and offers

This site uses technical cookies to guarantee an optimal and fast navigation, and analysis cookies to elaborate statistics.
You can visit the Cookie Policy to get more insights or to block the use of all or some cookies, by selecting the Cookie Settings.
By choosing Accept, you give your permission to use the abovementioned cookies.

Privacy Settings saved!
Privacy Settings

When you visit any web site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Control your personal Cookie Services here.

These cookies are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off in our systems.

In order to use this website we use the following technically required cookies
  • wordpress_test_cookie
  • wordpress_logged_in_
  • wordpress_sec

Decline all Services
Accept all Services
0